Some IF diets restrict eating during a certain time of day. Others limit the number of calories during a fasting period. And some people rotate between normal days and fasting days.
This article explores the science behind these eating plans, especially the effects they could have on people with diabetes.
History of Diabetes and Intermittent Fasting
Fasting has been around for a long time. It’s been a historical part of some spiritual traditions stretching back centuries. More recently, IF has been used as part of a healthy diet for weight loss, as a “detoxifying” strategy, and more.
There’s been some debate about whether fasting is healthy for those with diabetes. A growing body of evidence suggests that some IF diets could benefit people with diabetes. Scientists note that when a person fasts may be just as important as the diet itself.
Glucose Metabolism
To understand the benefits of intermittent fasting and diabetes, it’s good to know a little about how your body processes glucose and insulin.
Insulin is a hormone that enables glucose (sugar) to enter muscle, fat, and liver cells, where it’s used for energy. Normally, when blood glucose rises, the pancreas releases insulin. The insulin lowers blood sugar by “unlocking” cells so that they absorb sugar from the bloodstream. That’s how your body keeps blood sugar at a healthy level.
Insulin Resistance
Sometimes muscle, fat, and liver cells don’t respond normally to insulin. Glucose builds up in the blood because it can’t enter the cells. This is called insulin resistance. The cells resist the effects of insulin.
The pancreas responds by making more insulin. The extra insulin may keep the blood sugar level in a healthy range—until the pancreas can no longer make enough insulin to overcome the insulin resistance of the cells.
Prediabetes
Prediabetes means your blood glucose levels are higher than normal, but not high enough to qualify as diabetes. You may have prediabetes if you have insulin resistance. Prediabetes can also happen if your pancreas doesn’t make enough insulin to keep your blood sugar within the normal range.
Over time, prediabetes often progresses into type 2 diabetes.
How Intermittent Fasting Works
The primary goal of intermittent fasting for weight loss is to get insulin levels low enough so your body burns stored fat for energy instead of sugar.
Here is how it works: When your body breaks down the food you eat, it ends up as molecules in your bloodstream. One such molecule is glucose. It comes from the breakdown of carbohydrates.
Your body makes insulin so your cells can store and use that glucose. If you have more blood glucose than your body can use, it gets stored as fat for future use.
When you’re not eating meals or snacks, insulin levels drop. When insulin levels are low, fat cells release some of the stored fat so it can be used for energy. That results in weight loss.
Benefits of Intermittent Fasting
A few small studies have shown that intermittent fasting can have health benefits for people with diabetes.
The benefits include:
Weight lossLowering insulin requirements
A long-term study published in the New England Journal of Medicine showed that fasting can:
Lessen inflammationLower insulin levelsImprove a wide range of illnesses such as asthma, arthritis, and moreDetox the bodyHelp the body rid itself of damaged cells, which may lower the risk of cancer
Other reported benefits of fasting include:
Lower triglycerides and LDL (“bad”) cholesterol levels Lower blood pressure
Side Effects
Fasting has a few downsides.
Side effects of IF diets can include:
Bad breath (which often results from low-carb diets) Trouble concentrating Excessive hunger Irritability Insomnia Headaches Dehydration Daytime sleepiness Low energy levels that may impact your ability to exercise, which is important for people with diabetes A much higher risk of low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) High blood sugar (hyperglycemia) which can happen if the liver responds to fasting by releasing stored glucose
More research is needed to understand how common and how severe these side effects could be.
Types of IF Diets for Diabetes
Several IF diets have proven safe and effective for people with diabetes. Here’s a look at the research.
The 5:2 Diet
The popular 5:2 diet was introduced in Dr. Jason Fung’s best-selling book “The Obesity Code” in 2016. It involves eating a recommended amount of calories five days per week, with two non-consecutive days of eating a reduced-calorie diet. On fasting days, you don’t stop eating altogether. You just cut the number of calories.
If you have diabetes and want to try the 5:2 diet, speak to your healthcare provider or diabetic team. They’ll help you set a target calorie intake for the fasting and non-fasting days.
Studies on the 5:2 Diet
Studies have shown that the 5:2 diet may lower insulin resistance. It may also help with weight loss in people with type 2 diabetes or prediabetes.
The first long-term study of the 5:2 diet was published in 2018 by the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). It found that fasting could be effective for those with diabetes who have trouble sticking to a long-term, daily diet regimen.
The study tracked 137 people with type 2 diabetes:
Half of them followed the 5:2 diet. They fasted for two non-consecutive days per week, taking in 500 to 600 calories on the fasting days. They ate normally on the other five days. The other half ate a daily restricted diet of 1200 to 1500 calories per day.
The study found that those who followed the 5:2 diet were just as likely to control their blood sugar levels as those on the daily restricted-calorie diet. Researchers said the 5:2 diet “may be superior to continuous energy restriction for weight reduction.”
Safety of the 5:2 Diet
Some experts question the safety of the 5:2 diet for people with diabetes. But a long-term study published in 2018 reported that “fasting is safe for those with diet-controlled type 2 diabetes.”
This study found the 5:2 diet safe for those with diabetes. Still, it’s important to talk to your healthcare provider before fasting or starting any other type of diet.
Early Time-Restricted Feeding Diet (eTRF)
With an early time-restricted feeding (eTRF) diet, you fit all your meals into a specific period of time each day.
The eTRF diet plan may be an eight-hour, 10-hour, or even a six-hour plan. On the eight-hour plan, if you begin eating at 7:00 a.m., the last meal or snack for the day would be at 3:00 p.m. An example of the 12-hour early time-restricted feeding plan would be when you eat the first meal of the day at 7:00 a.m. and the last meal or snack no later than 7:00 p.m.
How the eTRF Diet Works
The eTRF diet may work with your circadian rhythm. Circadian rhythm refers to the body’s internal clock, which controls the timing of sleep, waking, and metabolism. That’s why some think the diet could aid weight loss.
If you stop eating earlier in the evening, you will extend your overnight fast. According to a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, fasting triggers some important cell functions, such as lowering blood sugar and boosting metabolism.
Benefits of the eTRF
Benefits of the eTRF diet include:
Less appetiteWeight lossMore fat loss via oxidation (burning of fat) Lower blood pressure
Study on the eTRF Diet for Diabetes
In a 2018 study, the eight-hour eTRF diet was compared with the 12-hour diet. The study found that the eight-hour group had dramatically lower insulin levels than the 12-hour group. Both groups maintained their weight. And both groups lowered insulin and blood pressure.
Tips for Intermittent Fasting When You Have Diabetes
Diabetes UK recommends that you follow these tips if you have diabetes and plan to start an IF diet:
Consult with your diabetes team about whether the diet is a good choice for you. Follow their advice on any changes to your medication schedule. You want to be sure to keep a healthy blood glucose level. Maintain a balanced diet during the fasting and non-fasting periods. Include foods from all of the food groups. Don’t overeat during the non-fasting periods. Just before you fast, eat foods that are more slowly absorbed. That includes those that are lower on the glycemic index scale. They’re often high in fiber and are digested slowly. Be sure to eat foods that fill you up and keep your blood sugar steady during the fast. Examples are fruits, vegetables, and fresh salads. When you break the fast, limit the amount of fatty or sugary foods you eat. Try grilling or baking instead of frying. Drink lots of fluids during the fast to avoid dehydration. Avoid sugary drinks. Test your blood glucose levels often. If you have symptoms of hypoglycemia, break the fast immediately. Use your action plan, such as taking glucose tablets followed by a snack. Talk to your healthcare provider before resuming the fast. If you have type 1 diabetes, watch for signs of hyperglycemia when you fast. These include fatigue, extreme thirst, and frequent urination. Contact your healthcare provider right away if you have these symptoms or your blood sugar level stays high.
Summary
Intermittent fasting is an eating plan that’s become popular for weight loss and detox purposes. There are questions about whether fasting is safe for people with diabetes. More research is needed, but some studies show there could be benefits for people with type 2 diabetes.
The 5:2 IF diet allows normal eating five days per week. On two non-consecutive days, you eat fewer calories. Studies show this plan is safe for people with type 2 diabetes that’s controlled with diet. If you take medications to keep type 2 diabetes in check, you will need to monitor your blood sugar closely to make sure it doesn’t drop too low.
Another popular fasting plan is early time-restricted feeding. This plan works by limiting the number of hours you can eat within a day. Eight-hour and 12-hour plans can lower insulin and blood pressure and help maintain weight.
If you have diabetes and want to try an IF diet, it’s vital that you work with your diabetes team to do it safely.
